The Reference Grade: How It Is Calculated in Switzerland
At a glance: A Swiss employment reference never contains a number like "grade 5". The overall grade follows from a fine-grained satisfaction scale (variations of adverbs such as "always" and "fullest"), together with the completeness of the conduct assessment and the closing formula. In Switzerland: grade 6 is the top grade (very good) and grade 1 the worst (insufficient).
"Which grade did I actually get?" is by far the most common question when reading a reference. If you understand the scale, you can assess your reference realistically and ask for specific corrections.
1. The Swiss grade scale: 6 is the top grade
A key difference from Germany or Austria: Switzerland uses the school grade system from 1 to 6:
| Grade | Verbal grade | Meaning in Swiss working life |
|---|---|---|
| 6 | Very good | Consistently outstanding top performance without reservation |
| 5 | Good | Above-average, solid performance (the Swiss HR standard) |
| 4 | Satisfactory | Average. Requirements met, but without particular commitment |
| 3 | Adequate | Below average. Clear reservations from the employer |
| 2 | Poor | Considerable shortcomings in performance or conduct |
| 1 | Insufficient | Complete failure to meet the requirements |
2. The satisfaction scale word for word
The overall grade for performance can be read off fixed formulations in the performance assessment:
| Wording in the reference | Grade | Details |
|---|---|---|
| "…always to our fullest satisfaction…" | 6 (very good) | Double intensification: always (consistently) + fullest (superlative). |
| "…always to our full satisfaction…" | 5 (good) | always present, but no superlative fullest. |
| "…to our full satisfaction…" | 4 (satisfactory) | The missing always signals: only occasionally good. |
| "…to our satisfaction…" | 3 (adequate) | Neither always nor full. A clear downgrade. |
| "…on the whole to our satisfaction…" | 2 (poor) | An explicit restriction (on the whole). |
| "…endeavoured to carry out the tasks." | 1 (insufficient) | Pure effort without proven success. |
3. The grade sits in the performance formula — the rest works alongside it
The satisfaction formula is not merely the best-known building block; it is the only one that carries a number. The other parts of the reference have no position of their own on the scale; they change the overall impression without moving the grade arithmetically:
- Performance assessment: carries the grade. If the satisfaction formula appears several times at different levels, the reference contradicts itself — the mean then counts, and on a tie the lower step.
- Conduct assessment: all three groups in the correct order (superiors, colleagues, customers). If superiors are missing, that is a clear warning sign — but not a deduction from the grade; it is a finding of its own.
- Closing formula: the trio of thanks, regret at the departure and good wishes for the professional future. A sparse closing formula next to grade 6 is a contradiction experienced readers notice.
Putting a percentage weighting over all sections ("performance 40 %, conduct 30 %, closing 30 %") invents numbers for sections that have none — and gives a different result for the same reference depending on interpretation.
4. How our automatic analysis determines the grade
That is exactly why our system does not calculate with such a weighting. When you analyse your reference, the grade is derived solely from the recognised steps of the satisfaction scale — deterministically, without discretion: the same document always gives the same grade, whether you upload it as a PDF or a DOCX, in English or in German. From it come a score (0 to 100 points) and the verbal grade (1 to 6).
The signals from conduct, leadership and the closing formula are not lost: they appear as individual findings with their own rating (positive, mild, clearly or strongly negative) next to the grade — where they belong, rather than being blended into a number nobody can follow.
- More tricky sentences are in the article The 10 most dangerous reference phrases.
- The complete reference language glossary explains every formulation in detail.