Confirmation of Employment vs. Full Reference: Differences, Rights & Strategy
At a glance: In Switzerland, Art. 330a CO provides for two different documents: the full reference (Vollzeugnis, with an assessment of performance and conduct) is the statutory norm. The confirmation of employment (Arbeitsbestätigung) is limited to facts (function & duration) and may only be issued at the employee's express request.
Anyone leaving a job receives a full reference by default. But the detailed reference is not always the best choice. When does a simple confirmation of employment make sense, what are the legal pitfalls, and how do the two documents differ in detail?
1. Detailed comparison
| Criterion | Full reference | Confirmation of employment |
|---|---|---|
| Legal basis | Art. 330a para. 1 CO (the norm) | Art. 330a para. 2 CO (on request) |
| Personal details & duration | Yes (name, date of birth, dates) | Yes |
| Description of duties | Yes, detailed tasks & responsibility | Yes, brief summary |
| Performance assessment | Yes (knowledge, quality, grade scale) | No (not permitted) |
| Conduct assessment | Yes (superiors, colleagues, customers) | No (not permitted) |
| Reason for leaving & closing formula | Yes (thanks, regret, wishes) | No |
| Meaning in applications | Standard for Swiss HR professionals | Signal of very short jobs or conflicts |
2. When does a confirmation of employment make sense?
Although the full reference is the norm, there are two scenarios in which a simple confirmation is strategically wiser:
Scenario A: Very short employment (under 2–3 months)
After a terminated probation period, a very short internship or a brief temporary assignment, a serious assessment of performance and conduct is hardly possible. A confirmation prevents speculation and looks professional.
Scenario B: Serious conflicts or a poor assessment
If the employment was marked by strong disagreements and a poor full reference (grade 2 or 3) is looming, switching to a confirmation may be the lesser evil.
Note: HR professionals know that applicants with a confirmation of employment often want to hide a difficult separation. A missing full reference almost always prompts questions in the interview.
3. Key legal rules for employers & employees
- The choice lies with the employee alone: The employer may not impose a confirmation of employment if the employee asks for a full reference.
- Switching later is possible at any time: If you first asked for a confirmation, you can still demand a full reference within the 10-year limitation period (Art. 127 CO).
- No hidden assessments in a confirmation: A confirmation may not contain disguised judgements (e.g. "Ms X was always punctual" in a simple confirmation is inadmissible).
4. Frequently asked questions
Can the employer refuse a confirmation of employment?
No. Under Art. 330a para. 2 CO the employer must comply with a request for a simple confirmation of employment.
How does our online tool assess a confirmation of employment?
Our analysis tool recognises confirmations of employment automatically. It gives them no fictitious grade but explains what they signal and which full reference you would be entitled to instead.
Next steps
- Read the guide to the Swiss grade scale (grades 1 to 6).
- Learn more about the correct structure of a full reference.